The website run by the people who manage the path is extremely useful.
They are overworked and understaffed, so don’t expect rapid replies
from email messages, but they are doing the best they can:
You’ll find a wealth of information there. What is below was written
for people like me—who might have more basic questions.
Are you safe?
Yes, you are safe. It is very unlikely that anyone will hurt or rob you.
Robbing or assaulting a tourist would bring shame to the village and family
of the perpetrator.
I saw women walking in the fields alone, and children playing unattended.
Remember too that every day for eight days my group of seven vagabonds
was invited into people’s homes for tea or coffee and that twice
those houses only had women in them. People don’t do that if they
don’t feel safe.
Nevertheless, the situation in Palestine, as far as the
overall security situation is concerned, is very complicated. I don’t
claim to understand it, but I do know that everyone I met, from the Israeli
soldiers who posed with me for a selfie, to the rabbi who invited me into
his house for coffee and sweets, to every Palestinian I met, was, at least
to me, very nice. Generally, though, I can say from everything I saw and
heard in Palestine and Israel, the ongoing Israeli occupation of
Palestine is one huge unconscionable human rights abuse and a monstrous
violation of international law.
Everyone I met was nice to me, for example, these Israeli soldiers I met outside a coffee shop in Jerusalem happily posed for a selfie with me.
Anyway, friends, be you American, Israeli, or Palestinian, your biggest
danger on the Masar Ibrahim or The Path of Abraham is yourself. If you
don’t carry enough water or you get lost in the desert, may God,
by whatever name you call him (or her), help you. Things could quickly get very serious
for you.
MORE PRACTICALITIES
Home-stay dinners like this one were a highlight of the trip.
In Palestine, you can drink the water straight from the tap and all the
food is as clean as you’ll find anywhere. The public transportation
system works reasonably well, and there is 24-hour electricity. As a hiker
your only problem is that on most of the walk there are no hotels and
camping is not possible. Which leaves home-stays as your only option.
Fortunately, the people who organized the trail have set-up home-stays
for hikers to stay in.
The home-stays are wonderful; don’t miss them, but they can vary
quite a bit. Sometimes we would arrive and only later learn, after dinner,
when the mattresses were pulled out from the back room, where we would
be sleeping. For the home-stays, it’s a good idea to carry your
own towel and, if not a sleeping bag, at least a bed sheet. Kindly remember
that the home-stays are in people’s homes and if you arrive in the
middle of the day when the family is occupied with daily tasks they may
not know what to do with you.
Breakfast on the trail.
If you are a vegetarian the home-stay cooks don’t seem to mind
cooking vegetarian food. If you want to get an early start, your hosts
will probably be happy to pack breakfast for you.
Our experience generally was that the families in the home-stays would
help us in any way they could.
I walked the entire path in low-cut light-weight walking shoes and never
had a problem, but others were glad that they wore hiking boots. Also
you should remember that you are traveling in a conservative society –
shorts and tank-tops are usually not culturally appropriate. Plus, most
people find that long sleeves and long pants protect them from the sun.
We carried our gear for about half of our walk. Then we discovered that
the taxi drivers were very happy to deliver our gear to our destination
for a reasonable price, so we did that.
DO YOU NEED A GUIDE?
Maybe.
I traveled with six other people, all of whom were experienced hikers
so we didn't bother with a guide. Without a guide, where there were roads,
we relied on printed maps, but, in the hills, our guides were the off-line
maps in our GPS phone apps. My experience is that using navigation apps
on streets and in the wide open spaces where there is no cell phone signal
are two very different experiences. So if you don’t have a guide,
you really should master your GPS and have a backup.
Having a guide in the desert would probably be a good idea.
As everybody says, when you're walking in the wilderness, don't walk
alone. I walked the entire 700 - kilometer Camino de Santiago alone but
I would never walk the Path of Abraham alone. If you twist an ankle, wander
off the path, or any other unimaginable calamity, you're going to have
a very serious situation if you are alone.
Will speaking English or Hebrew help?
This shepherd, who invited us to sit down for coffee, could speak some English.
English is taught in the schools in Palestine and many Palestinians
have worked in English-speaking countries so English is widely understood,
but usually not in small rural shops, or by shepherds. An Arab phrase
book or Google translate will help.
Hebrew will help if you meet one of the many Palestinians who have worked
or lived in Israel. Also many of the words (as is the culture) are similar.
An Israeli woman who had walked the trail told me that she did not detect
any animosity towards Israeli people from the Palestinians she met along
the path.
Those are the practicalities. Let me finish with a few highlights and
thoughts on human rights.
Someone told me that we received so much hospitality because the people were subtly interrogating us or because ours was a small group with women. For whatever reason, the hospitality we received was, to us, very touching.
My very basic understanding of hospitality in Palestinian is that in Arab culture if someone comes to your door,
you really should offer them hospitality and, if you have food, it
is rude not to share it.
Such is Palestinian hospitality that even as we walked past construction
sites where the workers were so far away that they could’t tell
if we were Israeli soldiers on an off-duty walk or foreigners, they would
shout out to us, “Welcome! Welcome!” which is a rough translation
of the Muslim greeting -- “Salami Alumina.”
You really have to be there to understand it.
Only the larger villages had falafel shops.
Another highlight was the food. When I walked the Camino de Santiago
in Spain, in 31 days I only had one good meal. In Palestine, every time
I sat down to eat I knew that this was going to be absolutely delicious.
One of the women I walked with told me, “When I go to India I lose
weight, when I come to Palestine I gain weight.” It’s not
that the Palestinian food is particularly fattening, it just tastes so
good that it’s hard to stop eating.
Finally, another highlight was coming to a much greater understanding
of how the Biblical prophets and holy men lived and traveled. Just after
the hike, I found myself in one of the popular Christian “holy places.”
People were touching relics, bowing their heads, saying prayers, and taking
selfies like crazy. As I saw them, I wanted to shout out, “Hey guys,
listen up! If you want to really experience the holy life, to walk in
the footsteps of the prophets, just go outside
and start walking. Don’t worry, have faith, everything is going
to be just fine."
The Church of the Holy Sepulcher in Jerusalem is probably the most
popular of the Christian places of pilgrimage.
Human rights
I didn’t go to Palestine to investigate human rights abuses; I
went there to go hiking. Here are simply my observations.
I decided to go to Palestine after a British woman, whom I will call
Jane, told me that it was safe. She had visited Palestine five times to
participate in the olive harvest and to volunteer in a cultural center.
She was planning to go on the hike and to work on a cookbook of her favorite
Palestinian dishes.
She and I arrived in Israel on different flights, but at
about the same time of day – late afternoon. As soon as I had passed
through immigration, I emailed her to ask her where we should meet. Jane
said that she was still in immigration and that I should go ahead into
town.
As I traveled on the train into central Tel Aviv I thought about
what an Israeli friend had told me: her brother had purchased an abandoned
barn and turned it into an artists’ studio. Later though, as Israel
has opened up a bit about its recent history, he learned that the original
owner had been forced out at gunpoint by Israeli soldiers decades earlier.
The next day I heard from my fellow hikers what had happened to Jane.
Looking through her passport, the immigration official noticed that she
had visited Israel five times in the last two years. He then searched
her name on-line and found on social media that she had enjoyed going
to Palestine. That was reason enough to tell her to her face that she
couldn’t enter Israel because she was likely to overstay her visa
and go underground. (Jane is fifty years old and has a house, family,
and a job in England.) She was then hauled off to a detention center.
It was about 6 in the evening.
As my fellow hikers told me the story, an Israeli friend of ours found
Jane a lawyer who immediately demanded a hearing to stop the pending deportation.
The hearing was granted a few hours later. During the brief hearing, the
judge said that Jane had “contradicted herself” during questioning
and should, therefore, be deported back to England because she could not
be trusted. What he meant by that was that the skillful Israeli interrogators
had played “good cop/bad cop” with Jane and tripped her up
somewhere.
By three PM Jane was on a plane back to England. My Israeli friend was
then forced to pay the court costs.
That was my introduction to human rights abuses in Israel and Palestine.
Examples . . .
As we walked, Palestine felt tranquil, hospitable, and often stunningly beautiful.
The walls of the living room of one of the houses that I stayed in during
the walk were filled with pictures of the family’s 16-year-old son
who had been shot in the leg by Israeli soldiers, denied medical treatment,
and left to bleed to death. There wasn't any "my son the martyr"
feeling in the house, rather, simply "my son is gone." It was
just pure sadness.
In another house I stayed in, the father of the house had worked in Israel
for years, gotten along well with his Israeli boss, and liked his job.
He told me that even though his permit to work in Israel was just for
the day-time, his boss let him sleep in Israel during the week to avoid
the hassle of the checkpoints. On the weekends, he continued, he returns to his village
in Palestine and farms. One Saturday he was using his tractor on his
land when Israeli settlers with guns approached him and told him to run
away. He did. The next day he returned to his land and found that his
tractor had been set ablaze by the Israelis.
At least half of the older men I met had spent time in Israeli prisons.
One man told me that he had spent two years in an Israeli prison and had
never known why he was there. He had simply been sleeping in his house
when soldiers came and took him away. That man later became a hotel operator
and told his story to a human rights lawyer who was passing
through; the lawyer took the case to court where he presented evidence
that proved the young man’s innocence. The Israeli judge, however,
said that the man, being 20, male, and living in an area that Israel wanted
to control was a "security risk." End of story.
Another man I met was studying hotel management when the Israeli soldiers
released tear gas in front of his house which promptly killed his father
who had breathing problems. Crazy with rage, the man rushed the nearby
Israeli soldiers with his bare hands, was shot twice, and then spent the
next seven years in prison.
After I decided to go to Palestine to hike, I agreed to make a movie
for a small charity. To get footage for the movie I visited Nablus University
to interview students. What impressed me about the students was how much
they were like me when I was a student. They were full of enthusiasm about
their lives, had an excess of boy/girl energy, and were looking forward
to their future careers as teachers, doctors, or in one case, as an actor.
The major difference between their student life and my own was that they
were living under occupation which they said was awful.
The students who commuted to class often had to endure time-consuming
checkpoints. The Israelis call the checkpoints a way to, "make our
presence known." The Palestinians call the checkpoints a humiliation.
I edited the movie in a village in Palestine. One day a friend took me
to his neighbor’s house so we could watch a rough draft of the movie
on their huge flat-screen TV. We knocked on the door and were told the
customary, "Welcome, come in, sit down. Would you like coffee or
tea? With or without sugar?"
It didn't seem to make any difference that we were totally unannounced
and that on that day the house was filled with young men who were watching
a soccer game on television while drinking tea. The young man who actually
lived there was about thirty, wore straight leg tight jeans, a T-shirt
emblazoned with pop art, and a long-sleeved denim jacket. I asked him
what he did for a living. He said that he worked in Israel.
"Legally or illegally?" I asked.
Israel has too many people who want to be doctors and professionals
and not enough people who want to pour coffee or do construction so the
clever Israelis legally or illegally employ thousands of people from around
the region to do what most Israelis don't want to do.
"Legally," he told me with some pride.
"How is it," I asked.
"The Israelis treat me like I am an animal."
"But the money is okay?"
"Better than I could make here."
"Good."
"Good, but I don't like being treated like an animal."
That young man was the only person I met who seemed to be a little bitter.
Everyone else seemed to have come to some kind of inner peace with what
had happened to them. Often I was told things like, "A man's religion
isn't important. What is more important is that he treats the whole world like he
treats his own family."
I should also note that some Israeli citizens do what they can to help the Palestinians and are ashamed at what their government
has done. One of them told me, “After the Six-Day War in 1967, Israel
lost its moral compass.”
Before I visited Palestine I had imagined meeting religious
zealots. But when I was actually there I didn't meet anyone who had the
slightest desire to tell me much about Islam and two of the men I met
were atheists, which didn't seem to be a problem for their family members.
The questions that I asked about Islam were answered courteously and in
detail. Looking back though, I wish that I would have asked more questions.
I did, however, learn a few things about the Israeli settlers. The settlements
themselves are rather like gated communities in the United States except
there are more guns, and soldiers providing “protection.”
(Settlers can have guns, non-settler-Israeli citizens can’t easily
get a gun.) In the settlements, like in a gated community, a person could
live there and not really have any contact with the people who live outside
the walls.
There are between half a million and 750,000 people living in the settlements
and all of them, according to international law, are living in Palestine
illegally. Their reasons for living in settlements vary from person to
person. Some people are settlers because housing is so cheap in the settlements
and, anyway, they can commute daily to the nearby Israeli cities. Other
people do it because they always wanted to be a farmer and knew that in
a settlement they could get cheap land and plenty of water (often stolen
from Palestinian springs). And still other people choose to live in a
settlement because they believe that is what God wants them to do.
The Israeli public in Israel proper is told that the settlements are
on land that is unused or unwanted. Most people in Israel, I was told,
are totally ignorant about what goes on in "the occupied territories."
And even the soldiers who are posted to settlements and are often shocked
at what they are asked to do.
While I was making the movie, for two days I attended one of these "peace
and reconciliation" gatherings. On this gathering, some Israeli citizens
from Jerusalem and Tel Aviv joined traveled to Palestine, which is very
easy for them to do, for the weekend. A highlight of the weekend was visiting
the house of a settler who lived about a 10-minute drive from the village
I was staying in. This particular settler was a Jewish rabbi who impressed
me when I met him as being a congenial and jolly man. Indeed, he welcomed
us into his house and served us coffee and snacks. As I heard him speak,
what was remarkable was that he reminded me of some of the racist preachers
I used to hear in the United States. Those preachers used to say things
like, "If the nee-gra lives in this area it will be unsafe for any
white woman to walk the streets" and "God wants the races to
live separately."
The congenial rabbi who invited us into his lovely house in a settlement shook hands with us after his lecture on the necessity of Zionism.
This rabbi spent his days teaching hatred to young Israelis. He taught
them that all Palestinians take particular joy in the death of an Israeli,
and that the will of God and the prophets was that the Israeli people
settle the land from the Mediterranean Sea to the Jordan River—much
of which belongs to the Palestinians. The rabbi believed that if the Palestinians
wanted to further the will of God they would be well-advised to move out
of Palestine and into Jordan. He encouraged us not to think in terms of
human rights or right and wrong but in terms of the will of God.
He also told us that there is no such thing as an American Jew, or a
French Jew, there is simply "a Jew." He felt that all Jews should
do everything they could to make sure that the will of God is carried
out. If the Jewish people worked together, he claimed, they would become
enlightened religious teachers who would lead the world.
A couple of the Westerners who were in the room with me were ready to
shout obscenities and storm out of the room as they heard the rabbi’s
racist rant. Fortunately, the Jewish people who had come from Tel Aviv
and Jerusalem kept things in the room calm and only later did they tell
us that they had been depressed and shocked by the rabbi's remarks. Later
one of them told me that religious zealots have taken control of much
of the Israeli government.
After the "peace and reconciliation weekend," one of the people
attending it gave me a ride into Jerusalem. The ride took less than an
hour and was, at least for me, dramatic.
The famous "separation barrier" as seen from Bethlehem,
Palestine.
As we got closer to Jerusalem, the number of fortifications and soldiers
increased dramatically. We seemed to be going through checkpoint after
checkpoint where people with machine guns looked at us, noted that we
were in a car with Israeli license plates, and waved us through. When
I asked the driver, if I could take pictures—she pointed out the
signs that said, "No pictures."
And then suddenly we were in Jerusalem where, like in Tel Aviv, almost
no one lives in a stand-alone house—everyone lives in some kind
of apartment building. Often those apartment buildings are along leafy
well-tended quiet manicured streets as indeed was my hotel, the Jerusalem
Castle Hotel.
I arrived in Jerusalem at 7 PM on a Saturday night. The first thing I
asked my hotel operator was, "Where can I buy beer?" He told
me that because this was the Jewish sabbath I would have to wait for darkness
which was coming in an hour at which time, he assured me, the stores would
reopen and I could buy a beer. I thanked him and in an hour or so enjoyed
a beer.
By 7:30 the next morning I had visited both the Church of the Holy Sepulcher
and the Wailing Wall. Both are in the "Old City" and within
a 15-minute walk of each other.
On the Dead Sea are small beach resorts like this one.
That afternoon I visited the Dead Sea, a 25-minute bus ride away from
Jerusalem, and on my last morning in Jerusalem, I visited the third most
holy place in Islam, The Dome of the Rock, and which is, conveniently,
located directly above the Wailing Wall.
A student takes a shortcut in front of the Dome of the Rock.
I found Jerusalem to be pretty creepy. Around many corners are soldiers
with machine guns. Many of those soldiers appeared to be young recruits
who were either on their way to work or on the way home from some kind
of training.
Someone told me that most of Israelis are the equivalent of, "Christmas/Easter
Christians." That is, they celebrate the holidays, and go through
some of the motions of Jewish life, but the finer points of Judaism don’t
interest them. However, the same person told me, most Jewish people living
in Jerusalem are there to make a political statement: "Israel is
the land of the Jews, I'm Jewish, get over it. This is mine." So
in Jerusalem you see all kinds of funny flags, funny hats and strange
hair-dos that the different Jewish sects think are important.
But there are a fair number of people dressed in traditional Muslim clothing
as well.
The Wailing Wall has different sections for men and women, above
it is the Dome of the Rock.
To tell you the truth, after I visited the Wailing Wall, I realized that
I was too traumatized by my experiences in Palestine to really enjoy Israel.
So I cut short my visit and went to Bethlehem, Palestine, a 25-minute
bus ride from Jerusalem.